What the Senate Permitting Bill means for Florida waters, and what you can do
What the Senate Permitting Bill means for Florida waters, and what you can do

The U.S. Senate is moving a sweeping permitting bill that would make it easier to fill wetlands, harder for states to protect their waters, and nearly impossible to stop a bad project in court.
On Nov. 9, the Senate voted 73–25 to begin debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653). Sponsors want it passed in the lame-duck session, before the new Congress arrives in January.
The promise is cheaper power and faster construction of transmission lines. But buried in its 400-plus pages are rollbacks to the Clean Water Act, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the Endangered Species Act, all crucial to clean water and wild Florida.
VoteWater opposes the bill and urges you to do the same (see below).
What It Does to Our Water
- Wetlands become easier to fill. Under the bill, filling up to 2 acres of wetlands would be presumed to cause “minimal” harm. Today’s limit is generally half an acre. The Army Corps could weigh only water quality factors, not flooding or wildlife. In a state that runs on wetlands, 2 acres at a time could add up fast.
- Pollution permits last twice as long. Discharge (NPDES) permits would run 10 years instead of 5. That means pollution limits written today could stay in place well into the 2030s, even if conditions get worse.
- States lose leverage. Under Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, states can attach conditions to federal permits, or deny them, to protect their own waters. BAAJA would require “clear and convincing evidence” before a state could act. For gas pipelines and transmission lines, states could look only at direct discharges. Senate leaders’ Nov. 7 revisions give states more say over which conditions they need, but the tough burden of proof remains.
- EPA’s last line of defense is weakened. The Environmental Protection Agency could no longer veto a destructive wetlands permit once it has been issued.
- Courts can’t stop bad projects. The deadline to sue under NEPA drops from as long as six years to 150 days. Even if a judge finds a project broke the law, the court could only send the permit back to the agency. Construction would keep going in the meantime.
- Federal money, no federal review. Projects paid for with federal grants or reimbursement would no longer trigger NEPA unless Washington controls them. That gives a state a cleaner path to build the next “Alligator Alcatraz” in Everglades without a full federal environmental review. New research that comes out after a review begins could be ignored.
- Endangered species lose backup. States could take over federal consultation on endangered species, and formal consultations would shrink from 90 days to 60. The revisions let regulators pull authority from states that fall short. That matters for manatees, sea turtles and other Florida species.
- Permits get harder to revisit. Once a project holds all its federal permits, agencies could revoke or change them only in narrow cases, such as violations or urgent threats. If an agency can’t justify stepping in, the developer can sue for reinstatement, delay costs and legal fees. In bad-faith cases, damages could reach 25–50% of project costs.
The Other Side, and What Comes Next
Supporters say lawsuits and permitting delays hurt solar, wind and transmission more than anyone. But the trade is lopsided. Gas pipelines get fast-tracked. Wetlands, state water authority and the public’s day in court get traded away.
Florida groups are pushing back too. On Nov. 13, Save the Manatee Club, Friends of the Everglades, Sea Turtle Conservancy, Miami Waterkeeper, Healthy Gulf and the Endangered Species Coalition called on Sens. Rick Scott and Ashley Moody to reject the bill. Both senators voted to advance it on Nov. 9.
After the Nov. 9 vote, the bill moves to Senate debate and amendments. The House has not taken it up.
What you can do: Call or email Sens. Rick Scott and Ashley Moody and tell them that cheaper energy shouldn’t come at the expense of clean water. Ask them to strip the Clean Water Act and NEPA rollbacks from BAAJA.